Landmark ruling on sex change

Email this storyPrint this story Wednesday November 22, 2000

The Chief Ombudsman has made a landmark recommendation that a person be given a sex change and the Health Funding Authority (HFA) foot the bill.

Sir Brian Elwood made his unusual recommendation to the HFA and Health Minister Annette King after ruling that the authority acted unreasonably in the case of Joanne Proctor, aged 52, who is now living as a woman in the King Country.

She was scheduled to have gender reassignment surgery in Waikato Hospital in 1997, when Midland Health, the now-defunct regional health authority, decided against funding sex changes.

In 1998, Ms Proctor, a former Christchurch crane driver, complained to Sir Brian, whose office launched an investigation into whether health authorities treated her fairly.

The HFA later conceded that she had been treated "with a degree of administrative unfairness."

This year, the HFA offered to assist Ms Proctor to make an application for surgery and to meet the cost of two psychiatric assessments. Progress has been slow.

Sir Brian has recommended that the HFA facilitate the psychiatric assessments urgently and has ordered it to pay for the gender reassignment surgery and all associated costs.

- NZPA