
9:30pm Wednesday, June
30 on TV One
This week's local Real Life
documentary Is She Or Isn't He? (tonight
at 9.30pm on TV ONE) tells the story of a
self-proclaimed 'fat, hairy woman with a penis' and her five-year search to
find love and acceptance.
Graham grew up as small town boy who believed he was a woman - he was clearly
an outsider and could only see one solution - to
change his gender. Graham decided to become Ashleigh, and so begins filmmaker
Justin Pemberton's five-year project documenting Ashleigh's attempt to
transition.
Pemberton met Ashleigh as Graham
six years ago and the film starts before she has told
her family about her plans, or even chosen her female name. Ashleigh tells
Pemberton that she is a woman with 'a deformity', and she wants more than
anything to be an attractive woman "with beautiful big breasts that a
[heterosexual] man would love."
At the start of
the film Ashleigh begins to wear makeup, starts
taking female hormones and getting laser treatments to remove
her manly hair. But despite her resolve, it's another two years before she
feels brave enough to actually dress as a woman. Just as Ashleigh starts to
really change her appearance, she also reveals the inner conflict and confusion
surrounding what she's doing.
Pemberton says of Ashleigh's
decision, "I was curious about how she could be so certain about her
sexuality and wanting to change her gender when she'd clearly not really
explored any other options,".
Ashleigh dreads being identified
as 'transgender' and after visiting an exhibition of
photographs of transgender women, leaves dismissive of those 'tragic
transgenders'.
But for Pemberton, seeing
Asleigh's attitude toward others who have also undergone gender transformation
is quite bizarre. "The painful irony is that she becomes transgender,
which is not considered by most to be 'normal'," he says.
Real Life: Is She or Isn't He? is
the longest documentary project ever commissioned by New
Zealand On Air and will undoubtedly provoke debate about how New
Zealanders define their sex and sexuality and how they deal with people seeking
transgender surgery.